The Out-of-Door Academy (PreK–12) — Private IndependentArea: Siesta Key (Lower) & Lakewood Ranch (Upper)
Website: https://www.oda.edu/Address: 444 Reid St, Sarasota, FL 34242 (Lower) • 5950 Deer Dr, Sarasota, FL 34240 (Upper)
Grades: PreK–12
Programs/Focus: College-prep; STEM; arts; athletics
Tuition: $$–$$$ (varies by grade)
Enrollment & Ratio: ~700–800 • ~9–10:1
Transportation: Private bus routes
Extracurriculars/Athletics: 13+ varsity sports; arts; service
Accreditations: FCIS; SAIS; NAIS/Cognia
Admissions: Application; deadlines vary
Diversity/Demographics: Inclusive community
Ratings/Accolades: Niche A+; often #1 private locally
Notes: Two campuses; strong college placement
Cardinal Mooney Catholic High School (9–12) — Private (Catholic)Area: Central Sarasota
Website: https://www.cmhs-sarasota.org/Address: 4171 Fruitville Rd, Sarasota, FL 34232
Grades: 9–12
Programs/Focus: College-prep; AP; athletics; faith-based
Tuition: $$ (aid available)
Enrollment & Ratio: ~600 • ~15:1
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Athletics; arts; service
Accreditations: Diocese; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Countywide draws
Ratings/Accolades: Niche A/A+
Notes: Strong academics & athletics
Sarasota Christian School (PreK–12) — Private (Christian)Area: Proctor / Beneva
Website: https://www.sarasotachristian.org/Address: 5415 Bahia Vista St, Sarasota, FL 34232
Grades: PreK–12
Programs/Focus: College-prep; arts; athletics
Tuition: $$ (varies)
Enrollment & Ratio: ~900 • ~12–15:1
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Athletics; arts; clubs
Accreditations: ACSI; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Countywide draws
Ratings/Accolades: Niche A-/B+ range
Notes: Longstanding K–12 Christian school
NewGate School (PreK–12) — Private (AMI Montessori)Area: Ashton Rd / Central Sarasota
Website: https://www.newgate.edu/Address: (see website)
Grades: PreK–12
Programs/Focus: AMI Montessori; inquiry; arts
Tuition: $$–$$$ (varies)
Enrollment & Ratio: Small cohorts; low ratios
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Arts; languages; clubs
Accreditations: AMI; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: International community
Ratings/Accolades: Niche A range
Notes: Internationally recognized Montessori
Hershorin Schiff Community Day School (K–8) — Private (Jewish, inclusive)Area: McIntosh / Central Sarasota
Website: https://www.hscds.org/Address: (see website)
Grades: K–8
Programs/Focus: Project-based; arts; world languages
Tuition: $$ (aid available)
Enrollment & Ratio: Small cohorts; low ratios
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Arts; clubs; service
Accreditations: Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Inclusive community
Ratings/Accolades: Niche A range (varies)
Notes: Inclusive, project-based learning
Incarnation Catholic School (PreK–8) — Private (Catholic)Area: Central Sarasota
Website: https://www.incarnation-school.org/Address: (see website)
Grades: PreK–8
Programs/Focus: Faith-based academics; arts/athletics
Tuition: $–$$ (parish/non-parish)
Enrollment & Ratio: ~400 • ~12–14:1
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Athletics; clubs; service
Accreditations: Diocese; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Parish + community
Ratings/Accolades: —
Notes: Parish school
St. Martha Catholic School (K–8) — Private (Catholic)Area: Fruitville / Central Sarasota
Website: https://www.stmarthaschool.net/Address: (see website)
Grades: K–8
Programs/Focus: Faith-based academics; arts/athletics
Tuition: $–$$ (parish/non-parish)
Enrollment & Ratio: ~400 • ~12–14:1
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Athletics; clubs; service
Accreditations: Diocese; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Parish + community
Ratings/Accolades: Niche A-/B+ range
Notes: Feeds to Cardinal Mooney HS
Epiphany Cathedral Catholic School (K–8) — Private (Catholic)Area: Venice
Website: https://www.ecstigers.com/Address: (see website)
Grades: K–8
Programs/Focus: Faith-based academics; arts/athletics
Tuition: $–$$ (parish/non-parish)
Enrollment & Ratio: ~400 • ~12–14:1
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Athletics; clubs; service
Accreditations: Diocese; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Parish + community
Ratings/Accolades: —
Notes: Parish school in Venice
Venice Christian School (K–12) — Private (Christian)Area: Venice
Website: https://www.venicechristian.org/Address: (see website)
Grades: K–12
Programs/Focus: College-prep; arts; athletics
Tuition: $$ (varies)
Enrollment & Ratio: Small school; low ratios
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Athletics; arts; clubs
Accreditations: ACSI; Cognia
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Countywide draws
Ratings/Accolades: Niche B range
Notes: Christian worldview; tight community
The Classical Academy of Sarasota (K–12) — Private (Classical Christian)Area: Central Sarasota
Website: https://www.tcacademy.org/Address: (see website)
Grades: K–12
Programs/Focus: Classical curriculum; Latin; Rhetoric
Tuition: $$ (varies)
Enrollment & Ratio: Small cohorts; low ratios
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Clubs; arts; service
Accreditations: —
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Countywide draws
Ratings/Accolades: —
Notes: Classical Christian model
Providence Community School (K–12) — Private (Hybrid/Christian)Area: Sarasota
Website: (search “Providence Community School Sarasota”)
Address: (see website)
Grades: K–12
Programs/Focus: Hybrid classical model; faith-based
Tuition: $–$$ (varies)
Enrollment & Ratio: Small cohorts
Transportation: Family-arranged
Extracurriculars/Athletics: Clubs; service
Accreditations: — (verify)
Admissions: Application
Diversity/Demographics: Countywide draws
Ratings/Accolades: Niche high marks locally
Notes: University-model schedule